feedback about redesign

For an assignment in a course on User Interfaces and Design at Brown University, my group and I redesigned a site that provides student reviews of University courses here: http://nikitaramoji.com/critical-review/.

I was hoping to get feedback about things we did well and things we could improve on!

Note: the site is not functional - we implemented a redesign of some key features!

Screenshots of the original site are here: https://imgur.com/a/g509y