CRUD without READ (detail)

Background

We have a list of users. Now the users have a button Edit that leads him directly to an edit screen:

enter image description here

In other parts of the app we have a similar list just there we have a Detail button that brings a user to a Detail first and then he can start editing.

Questions

  • Is it a bad practice to skip Detail view?
  • Is the inconsistency that bad?
  • If the pattern is fine, should the Edit mode be presented in popup?

Tags

I'm a UX newbie and don't know what tags to use. If u had an idea, please update the question.

Tags: