Is asking ‘balanced’ leading questions the right way during user interviews?
It sounds a little bit counter-intuitive, but I am wondering if we actually lose a lot of the information that we might otherwise intend on finding out or capturing by not asking more direct or ‘leading’ questions.
Conventi…
Can someone tell me SIMPLY the difference between site maps and IA Document?
1ST QUESTION: What is the difference between these two types of paper or electronic documents often created during a UX process for a website or app:
1) Information Architecture document (IA Hierarchy or IA Diagram or IA Model)
2) Site Map
NOTE: By site map I am NOT talking about a graphical representation of a website that used to be a common feature of web sites in the early 90’s nor do I mean the file used by search engine robots…I’m talking about a paper or electronic document a UXer would create.
If you put the two documents side by side what would be the difference between the two for the same site or app?
I was postulating that maybe the difference is, bottom line, that an IA document is about identifying content types or categories while a site map document is about how one would navigate to that content but I’m not sure. Both documents present organizational structures for content.
Could one say that the IA document is about the content types or categories your site will have as in “my site will have page about dogs” while the site map shows where the dog content will be located in your Pet Store’s web site hierarchy and how users will be able to navigate to it?
2ND QUESTION: Should the FUNCTIONS one can do on a site or an app be part of either a Information Architecture document OR a site map OR both? By function, I mean like in a task management app, being able to attach a document to a task you’ve created is a function.
Suggestion required for max width of a form
My team is building a form builder tool. Once published there might be several input devices a user can use to fill a form, from a mobile phone to a 27″ monitor.
I would like to hear your ideas on the max width a form should take on a 27″ monitor if the browser window is opened in full – 3360 × 2100 / 4k.
Meeting Expectations: An Interview With Kevin M. Hoffman
Kevin M. Hoffman has been a designer for more than 15 years now, and in that time worked on small libraries, the University of Baltimore, Nintendo, MTV, and the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. We caught him between meetings to share a few thoughts about his favorite tool, conversational interfaces, and meeting design.
How’d you get your start in design, and on the web, if the two are different?
My first taste of both web and design work was in graduate school during the mid-1990s. I helped build a tool that allowed community organizations to perform property database searches. It helped them identify delinquent property owners in economically challenged areas. It was a trial by fire, as it was for most people building websites in those days. You just designed and built the thing! And then checked that thing in Mosaic and Netscape 2.
Processes for working together have become a lot more formalized since then, and mostly for the better. However, I do believe that a little bit of that “wild west attitude” has a place in our work.
You design meetings. Meetings are a thing you can design? How so?
You can definitely design meetings, and just about anything else. To design a thing means two checkboxes are checked: you’ve determined a desired outcome, and there is consideration for how people actually use or experience the thing. Painful meetings often fail on one of those two fronts.
Meetings often happen out of habit rather than intention, which fails the first checkbox. Typically, there’s not a clear, shared understanding of a specific outcome for each meeting, other than “be more further along than where we were when we started.” How do you measure that? How do you prove it? You can’t do either, really.
In terms of consideration of users, meetings can treat “meeting users,” or attendees, horribly. We don’t fully engage the brain, and fall back on listening as a primary method of accomplishing a goal. It’s as if a website only expected you to read body copy, with no thought to headings or visual ways of communicating ideas. The user experience of reading lines and lines of copy is mentally exhausting. The user experience of sitting in conversational meetings can be exhausting for the same reason.
You’re giving a talk called “The Five Meetings” this year at AEA. It’s clearly about meetings, but what will people take away from it?
Two things. First of all, I hope people come away with the belief no one is powerless to change the kinds of meetings they have in their organization. Not everyone is in a position where they can call, or even lead, a meeting, but everyone has a shared responsibility for the quality of that time together. There are simple things you can do—structures to fall back on, conversational hacks, and ways of changing the lens on a topic—to improve them.
Second, that even though some of us follow a prescribed set of meetings, either by process—agile, waterfall, or making it up—or by culture—conservative large company, startup, or one-person shop—we all share a lot more struggles, project to project, than we realize. I’m looking forward to hearing everyone talk to each other about all the meetings and meeting challenges they have in common, and being a part of that conversation. That’s where the best insights happen: the conversations after a talk!
What are some tools, tricks, and/or techniques you can’t work without?
Any tool that is designed for groups to use together, rather than individuals to use alone. Current examples include Google Docs, Slack, Dropbox, Github, and a tool I’m working on with some really smart friends called Boardthing. I absolutely cannot work without a place to draw what I’m thinking. I also can’t work without breaks, and lots of them!
What has you most excited these days?
I’m super excited about conversational interface systems. In the technology space, I really think Apple has its work cut out for it when you look at Siri’s performance compared to Google Now or Amazon Echo, in terms of making people’s lives easier. I do think Siri does well in specific situations, such as Homekit or the Apple TV, but general-purpose use isn’t quite as smooth as Android, in my experience. Conversational interfaces can certainly be awkward at first, and honestly feel a little like science fiction to an organization that isn’t designing for them yet. But using tools like IBM’s Watson API, it’s not really that hard for anyone to build that kind of logic into websites and applications.
Kevin will present “The Five Meetings” at An Event Apart Washington DC, July 25-27, 2016 . Don’t miss out on this essential information—plus eleven other great presentations for people who create digital experiences.
Is there a median SUS score for internal-facing apps, vs customer-facing apps?
I am about to execute a System Usability Scale survey for an app that is only used within our organization, not by the general public. I understand that the median score for all apps is 68, and am expecting a bit lower score …
Does the user want a notification when an action is performed successfully?
Is it good practice or not to give the user a notification of a successfully performed action? Like saving or deleting an item. Is it annoying and excessive or is it useful?
I am mostly referring to a toast notification, i…
Terminology for different kinds of ‘center’?
Mathematically there are various ways to calculate a spacial center point. (2d or 3d).
Barycenter (sum of all positions divided by the total number of points)
Bounding box center (typically the middle of the bounds on each …
Compact checkbox inputs
How is this in terms of usability?
It’s maybe not obvious you can switch those elements, is it still an intuitive way to represent a checkbox input?
Checking dependant checkboxes
In the admin UI of our system we have two check boxes that represent permissions:
View Foo
Edit Food
Checking a check box means granting a permission. There is an important dependency that we are struggling to enforce at …
What is the best way to align a paragraph beside an image?
The webpage has small paragraphs (5-6 lines) with images on the right of each paragraph. The text in paragraph is left aligned. The paragraph is not always as big as the height of the image that is on its right. What is the b…