"Are you sure?" Request for confirmation modal usability research

  1. A user is about to delete a crucial object with no undo.
  2. The designer puts an "Are you sure?" modal confirmation.
  3. The user says "Yeah yeah yeah do it"
  4. Immediately the user regrets his/her decision and panics.

Clearly Undo would be great. But sometimes that is impractical.

Question:

  • What public usability studies are there on this topic?
  • Do users REALLY think about the question or do they just click Yes without thinking?

Thank you.